Shark Week on Discovery

[nauifins]

Just curious as to what other divers think about Shark Week on the Discovery Channel? Tonights episode was full of misinformation and poor producing. It is doing more to harm our sharks than to protect them and educate the public.

Just my 2 cents.

[James Goddard]

Actually, though I'm a big fan of edutainment shows I tend to tune out during shark week. Just not really my cup of tea.

[theskull]

Shark week on Discovery channel is about as entertaining and factual as Nazi week on History channel.

Sensationalism, drama, elaborate fake reenactments, luring people in with shock value and keeping them tuned in to see the train wrecks. They're both sad and poor excuses for journalism.

theskull

[Walt Stearns]

Amen to that.

I have been in involved in more than a couple documentary shoots - three of which have aired on the Discovery Channel. What I am amazed by most of all, is the often times the action story that unfolds during the shoot is often times better than what rolls out of the editing room with the really good, factual stuff left sitting on the cutting room floor.

The main force behind this is the producers want/need to sell the program, sadly clients like Discovery Channel want/need sensationalism to draw the average viewer in. Take TV News for example. Facts are secondary, but if it bleeds, it leads.

[James Goddard]

Speaking of sharks, I first heard this story on NPR and thought it was interesting:

http://www.oceansentry.org/lang-en/m...otections.html

Nearly a dozen shark-attack victims — many of them badly scarred or missing limbs — pressed Congress on Wednesday to protect a sea creature they'd rather not run into again. The group wants to strengthen laws protecting sharks from "finning," in which fins are sliced from sharks for their meat, leaving the fish for dead. The growing market for fin meat, a popular soup delicacy in Asia, threatens many shark species around the world, they say.
Anderson and other attack victims wore white T-shirts reading "Shark Attack Survivors for Shark Conservation" as they met with senators and staffers. The lobbying blitz was organized by the Pew Environment Group to pass a bill strengthening language in an existing ban on finning in U.S. waters.
The measure, which supporters say would close loopholes and allow for stronger enforcement, easily passed the House by voice vote in March and has been introduced in the Senate by Sen. John Kerry, D-Mass. Among other things, it would prohibit sea vessels from carrying illegal fins whether they fished them or not, and it would allow the U.S. to call attention to other nations that are not following through with finning bans.
Anderson and Al Brenneka, who lost his right arm to a seven-foot lemon shark while surfing off Delray Beach, Fla., in 1976, said their attacks prompted them to learn more about sharks and, ultimately, to believe that humans are a far greater threat to them than they are to people.
Shark attacks are extremely rare. There were 59 worldwide last year, four of them fatal, according to George Burgess, a leading shark expert who directs the International Shark Attack File at the University of Florida's Museum of Natural History.
Meanwhile, a study released last month by the International Union for Conservation of Nature found that roughly a third of all sharks worldwide are in danger of extinction. The threatened species include hammerheads, the great white and mako sharks.
The organization said sharks killed at sea are often used only for their fin meat or are incidental bycatch as fishermen seek tuna and swordfish. Finning has been banned in most international waters, but advocacy groups say the rules are poorly enforced.